The 13 Most Painful K-Pop Idol Group Departures, According To Fans

If you’ve been a K-Pop fan for a decent length of time, you’ve likely gone through the heartbreaking journey of seeing a member leave a group that you like at some point. While sometimes these departures seem to happen amicably and with the idols still remaining good friends, it seems more often than not that they happen suddenly and without warning, and sometimes no explanation is ever given. Recently on Reddit, K-Pop fans were asked to name which idol departures from their groups were the most painful for them, and these are 13 of their top answers.

1. Hwall (former THE BOYZ)

Comment
by u/Bleue11 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Laziboii613 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/cici_kathleen from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/deaththekiddie from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/MeechiJ from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

2. B.I (former iKON)

Comment
by u/highhiloona from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/vanillapinkk from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/ContrastiveSol from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/palmfrondy from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Slow-Relation-9186 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

3. Love (former OnlyOneOf)

Comment
by u/starboardwoman from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/abnegwrites from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/sadly_sapphic from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Sister_Winter from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Clear-Ideal4231 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/jvhobee from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Rivsmama from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

4. Wonho (former MONSTA X)

Comment
by u/Chaeji412 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/rotten-dreams from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/NoCode5313 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Aqua_TofANNA from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/woolucky from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/palmfrondy from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Joobebe514 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Suitable_Wonder_3285 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

5. Luhan (former EXO)

Comment
by u/mariesnowelle from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/newhairnewtee from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/vanillapinkk from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Interesting-Snow6252 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/cmq827 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/newhairnewtee from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

6. Mashiho & Yedam (former TREASURE)

Comment
by u/Laziboii613 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/joesen_one from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/AdMore2091 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/SunnyBubblezz from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/findingpathsoonanna from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/chimmyyeah from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Spare923 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

7. Jinni (former NMIXX)

Comment
by u/animalcrossinglifeee from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/mcslay666 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/nmixxchangeup1 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/arctic1975 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/bifuku from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

8. Soojin (former (G)I-DLE)

Comment
by u/BunnyInTheM00n from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/PokemonLv10 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/jantp from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/lucegranate from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/2muchtaurine from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/iStayDemented from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

9. Ella & Satbyeol (former PIXY)

Comment
by u/Unofficial-Kpop-Dad from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/leashall from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/MoomooBlinksOnce from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/TheRealTerwilliger from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

10. Jessica (former Girls’ Generation)

Comment
by u/EmotionalGate7137 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/yuyu2007 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/mad_titanz from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/exsensepng from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/mansanhg from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

11. Jiyoon (former Weeekly)

Comment
by u/ImpactMaleficent5374 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/saddlethehippogriffs from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Barnabas-Tharmr from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/TheOpendBjoerkHouse from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/FunnyBeeDaileee from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

12. Ravn (former ONEUS)

Comment
by from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/_Daydream08_ from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/MeechiJ from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/kcey9090 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

13. Naeun (former Apink)

Comment
by u/mad_titanz from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/ryand89 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/rusadulgokraka from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts

Comment
by u/Rough_Maintenance_13 from discussion Which "member departure" situation hurt you the most, please…?
in kpopthoughts