aespa’s Shocking Change In Visuals Since Debut Triggers Scathing Reactions

aespa‘s changing visuals since debut have become a hot topic among Korean netizens after a recent viral post sparked heated debate online.

The post features a throwback photo from around the “Next Level” era and shows the members during their rookie days as well as their distinctive looks at the time.

In the photo, Ningning is seen with vibrant red hair, Winter sports her now-iconic bob with bangs, Karina appears with long black hair, and Giselle has soft wispy bangs. The image has sparked divided reactions, with some arguing that nearly every member’s visual has shifted significantly over the years — except for Giselle.

The post claims that Karina, Winter, and Ningning all had “baby fat” during their debut days, and their current appearances are noticeably different. Giselle, on the other hand, is described as having changed the least, retaining much of her original look.

Isn’t Giselle the one who’s changed the least in aespa?? Don’t you think so??

Karina, Winter, and Ningning all had baby fat back then.

— Viral Pan post

However, reactions in the comment section have been anything but unanimous. While some netizens agree that Giselle has maintained her features the most, others argue that Karina and Winter haven’t changed much either. One comment even criticizes the constant focus on aespa and IVE’s appearance.

Some have taken a harsher stance, suggesting aespa fans should revisit the Black Mamba music video to see how different the members looked with early-stage makeup and styling.

• “No way, Karina and Winter haven’t changed much either.”
• “If we’re talking about who changed the most since debut, it’s actually Hong Eunchae from LE SSERAFIM. But people always talk about aespa or IVE like they’re the only ones who changed.”
• “MYs should be forced to rewatch the Black Mamba music video from time to time as a reality check. Who even did their makeup back then?”
• “Karina looks pretty much the same though.”
• “Yeah, I agree about Hong Eunchae. She really gives off a different vibe now compared to debut.”