2023 “MAMA Awards” Draws Criticism From Korean Netizens Following Line-Up Announcements
This year’s Mnet Asian Music Awards (MAMA), one of the most prestigious events in the Asian music industry, is currently facing significant criticism from Korean netizens. A post on popular community site TheQoo has garnered more than 44,000 views and over 220 comments, illustrating the deep-rooted dissatisfaction among Korean fans.
The main bone of contention seems to be MAMA’s unconventional approach to revealing their anticipated line-up for the event. Instead of straightforward announcements, the organizers have opted for a daily puzzle reveal, challenging fans to decode the names of the performers from cryptic clues.
[#2023MAMA] ⚠SPOILER ALERT⚠ #1
Who are the PERFORMERS on 2023 MAMA AWARDS?
2023 MAMA AWARDS를 빛낼 퍼포밍 아티스트는?🔑SECRET CODE : 12 5 19 19 5 18 1 6 9 13
ONE I BORN
2023 MAMA AWARDS
2023.11.28(TUE)-29(WED) 6PM(KST)#MAMAAWARDS #2023MAMAAWARDS pic.twitter.com/1ZJXyDRhoQ— MAMA AWARDS (@MnetMAMA) October 20, 2023
One such puzzle had the organizers post a series of numbers arranged in a calendar-like pattern. Fans, being the dedicated detectives they are, matched the numbers to the positions of letters in the alphabet. The result was the word “LE SSERAFIM.”
In another instance, numbers corresponded to an old-style phone keypad, producing the word “RIIZE.” While some fans enjoyed the challenge, many felt it was a convoluted way of unveiling something as crucial as the performer line-up.
777 = R
444 = I
444= I
9999= Z
33= E
so riize will attend and perform at MAMA awards 😭😭 https://t.co/74l89usiBM pic.twitter.com/cz8JICyYX6— ✾ (@riizebot) October 21, 2023
The first major criticism is regarding the complexity of these puzzles. MAMA’s tradition of announcing the line-up is a greatly anticipated event. Fans wait with bated breath to know if their favorite groups or artists will be gracing the MAMA stage.
By turning the announcement into a game, the organizers have added an element of frustration for many. Korean netizens argue that the essence of the announcement is lost in translation, literally and figuratively. Instead of the excitement and anticipation, there’s now confusion and exasperation. They believe that a straightforward announcement would serve the purpose and respect the fans’ enthusiasm.
- “Why won’t they just reveal everyone at once?”
- “We already know which groups are most likely to attend, though. Lmao. This is f*cking extra.”
- “Are they really going to do this for every group every day…?”
- “I hate MAMA, and I don’t want to support them. But it’s one of the most sought-after award shows by idols, including my biases, so it’s annoying AF.”
The second point of contention is the language of these announcements. For an event rooted in Korean culture and primarily catering to Korean artists, the choice to make announcements exclusively in English has struck a wrong chord with many.
📣 2023 MAMA AWARDS voting starts NOW 📣
here’s how to vote for your faves on Spotify this year! pre-voting is open until Oct 30, 23:59 KST.
don’t forget: only the first 3 streams per user per day count as votes, so stream wisely!#2023MAMAxSpotify #2023MAMAAWARDSxSpotify pic.twitter.com/99DrNCajaN
— MAMA AWARDS (@MnetMAMA) October 20, 2023
Language, as we know, isn’t just a medium of communication but also an embodiment of culture and identity. By sidelining Korean in favor of English, the organizers seem to have inadvertently alienated a section of their core audience.
- Even the i-fans hate this…
- Oh? I didn’t even know this is still a thing. Lmao.
- Ever since they started hosting the show overseas, I stopped looking forward to it. Haha.
- I don’t really mind the little stuff like this, but I actually think it’s the dumbest thing that they’re hosting the show in Japan.
Fans believe that while international outreach is essential, it shouldn’t come at the expense of the native audience. Balancing global aspirations with local sensibilities is crucial, especially in an industry where fans play a pivotal role in an artist’s success.
