Former “Copycat” Comments Against Dancer Vata Arise Amid Backlash For Response To Plagiarism Accusations
By now, you’ve probably heard about the ongoing plagiarism accusations against Street Man Fighter contestant Vata for his “New Thing” dance choreography challenge.
vata needs to apologize to ateez + the og choreographers and credit them
SAY MY NAME#driving_dance_challenge #SayMyName_ATEEZ #ATEEZ #에이티즈 @ATEEZofficial pic.twitter.com/SHICBYRgzN
— illumi’s needle is seeing ATZ (@WHORESCOPE_1117) October 10, 2022
For a quick recap, the dancer was accused of copying the “driving” dance move from ATEEZ‘s “Say My Name” choreography, which was created by Anze Skrube, Josh Smith, and Johnny Erasme. ATEEZ member Wooyoung seemingly made a subtle call-out about the plagiarism, and Anze Skrube himself also made a personal statement on the issue recently.
anze himself saying there is a difference in just copying a move or copying a whole sequence and thats what happened here, a whole sequence was copied. again also said josh smith specifically created this sequence at the end of 2018 for ateez to use in 2019 for say my name! pic.twitter.com/FLBG1rfrOi
— dee (@azfxon) October 11, 2022
Earlier today, Vata finally made a response to the accusations by denying any plagiarism on his part.
This is Vata.
I thought this would be a cold wind that would breeze by, but I am writing this to stop the misunderstandings.
When I first heard the song, I thought of the wilderness and so I made the intro of riding a horse or motorcycle. That’s why in the beginning, there is a motion of kicking to start the engine and a motion of getting off the bike. These are parts of one move that transition from one to the other.
I think the choreography its being compared to has a different transition and means something different entirely.
As someone who loves the dance culture, I believe it is at its best when the artist and dancer respect one another. It saddens me to see that this isn’t taking place.
Regardless of the reason, I apologize to viewers of Street Man Fighter and to those who root for We Dem Boyz for any controversy that had occurred on my behalf. I will repay you by putting on a better stage.
— Vata
His lack of accountability and seemingly shady response towards the people asking for an apology has been met with scathing responses from both ATINYs and netizens as a whole.
vata said he was recreating the movement of riding a motorcycle? he did not apologize to ateez or the choreographers but instead to fans watching the show?? he said his sequence and smn’s sequence are different??? he thanked his fans for their support???? i feel sick
— winnie! (@hongteezer) October 14, 2022
“What does everyone else (non-ATINYs) think about the (Vata) statement?”#ApologizeToATEEZ #ApologizeToJosh #ATEEZisTheReal #에이티즈 @ATEEZofficial #ATEEZ pic.twitter.com/F2IieB5qRk
— ateez on reddit (@atzonreddit) October 14, 2022
Vata this is how you ride a bike with the right choreo #막상글은올렸지만너무무섭다#ApologizeToATEEZ #ApologizeToJosh #ATEEZisTheReal #SayMyName #ATEEZ #에이티즈 pic.twitter.com/rlk9jjaBqi
— Michaela ATSD 📌 (@iMikkiii) October 14, 2022
They even got “ApologizeToJosh” trending on social media in response to Vata’s statement, continuing to demand proper credit for “Say My Name” choreographer Josh Smith.
A real professional would assume his mistake and apologize.
ATEEZ, Anze Skrube, Josh Smith and Johnny Erasme deserve a real apology.RESPECT ATEEZ#ApologizeToATEEZ#ApologizeToJosh #ATEEZisTheReal#SayMyName#ATEEZ #에이티즈 #エイティーズpic.twitter.com/d7nyQvj5CA
— TR⩜⃝NSL⩜⃝TINY 📝 (@ATEEZtranslati1) October 14, 2022
You sought this as a “cold breeze”, well let us show you what a cold hurricane feels like!
Atinys will not be silenced! Ateez and Anze deserve justice.#막상글은올렸지만너무무섭다#ApologizeToATEEZ #ApologizeToJosh #ATEEZisTheReal #SayMyName@ATEEZofficial— ATEEZ(에이티즈)fp (@AteezOfficialfp) October 14, 2022
This is what he calls “completely different” 🤡 wbdz vata please open your eyes and lower your ego!!!!!! #ApologizeToJosh https://t.co/1A51PrLr06
— ainz (@ainsleejennu) October 14, 2022
Amid the backlash against the Street Man Fighter contestant, further accusations of plagiarism and copying other dancers have arisen against Vata and his crew, We Dem Boyz.
During the first episode of Street Man Fighter, the crews on the show were allowed to “vandalize” each other’s rooms. A photo of a flag that was allegedly in the room belonging to We Dem Boyz was shared after the vandalism occurred, and what was written on it may be suggesting past behavior of the crew and its members.
The comments on the flag include:
- (Written on the paper) “Melvin copycat ㅋㅋㅋ” and “JBLAZE copycat”
- (the comment circled with the hearts) “JBLAZE copycat”
- “This is SMF but they said they’re going to do Street Boy Fighter after!!”
- “Tristan copycat”
- “We Dem Kid”
- “Some people might think you made Fear of God”
- “Some people might think you also made Essentials”
- “If you mess with us”
- (knife) “You need to practice dancing. ‘You should dance the same dance at least, you guys are a team'”
- “Vata [cut off] Melvin copycat”
While multiple accusations of copying choreography from other dancers are made against the crew and Vata himself, one of the more notable names mentioned is JBLAZE. JBLAZE is, in fact, Johnny Erasme, one of the previously mentioned choreographers that helped create the dance for “Say My Name”.
so someone just sent me this, this is crazy. in the first episode of smf the crews went to eachothers rooms to ‘vandalize’.
look what they wrote on wdbz’s flag. the crew wrote ‘copied jblaze’ TWICE. johnny erasme aka jblaze is one of the say my name choreographers. pic.twitter.com/BCbrYgmBkL
— dee (@azfxon) October 13, 2022
Allegedly among the accusers was 1MILLION, one of the more professional and well-known crews performing on the show as they are from the famous 1MILLION Dance Studio.
basically this is not the first time they have been accused of copying choreographies from famous dancers. and when u have a huge name like 1million doing it, its not looking good i fear since they are professionals too.
— dee (@azfxon) October 13, 2022
Since this was done earlier in the season, the comments made during this “vandalizing” likely have no correlation to those made against Vata more recently. However, if the accusations of past instances of copying other choreographers’ dances is true, then it potentially shows a pattern of behavior against the We Dem Boyz members.
this might not have anything to do with the atz situation and its just a coincidence that jblaze also helped choreograph say my name but the fact we dem boyz has been accused of copying jblaze, melvin timtim and tristan edpao by 1MILLION says enough about their history
— dee (@azfxon) October 13, 2022
Of course, this is all still alleged at this time, as the exact context of what was written on the flag is unknown. What fans and netizens really want at this point is just a more acceptable response from Vata in regard to the “Say My Name” plagiarism accusations.
justice will prevail.
RESPECT ATEEZ#막상글은올렸지만너무무섭다 #ApologizeToJosh #ApologizeToATEEZ #ATEEZisTheReal #SayMyName #ATEEZ pic.twitter.com/HwtNOA55gA
— UPDATEEZ (@updateez) October 14, 2022
We sincerely hope that ATEEZ’s members and choreographers are doing well despite this ongoing issue.