Congo, Palestine, And Korean Workers’ Strike — TXT’s Collaboration With Samsung Leaves Many MOAs Upset Over Moral Implications
TXT recently released a new song, “Open Always Wins,” in collaboration with Samsung for the launch of its new mobile phone, Galaxy Z Flip 6. The song is also Samsung’s tagline as a sponsor of the Paris Olympics 2024.
While big-name brand endorsements and collaborations are usually considered achievements in K-Pop fandom spaces, in recent times, more and more fans have become cautious of what kind of brands their favorite idols are associated with. A brand’s sociopolitical affiliation has rapidly become a point of consideration among K-Pop fans, largely owing to the pro-Palestinian movements within the subculture. As a result, idols’ association with brands like Starbucks, McDonald’s, or even the luxury superbrand LVMH has been criticized and boycotted by many.
TXT’s song for Samsung is also seeing a similar pushback from their fanbase, MOA. But there are a multitude of reasons behind this, the first point of contention being Samsung’s possible contribution to the inhumane labor exploitation in Congo. The Democratic Republic of Congo is said to be going through a “silent genocide” as millions of children are forced to work in fatally unsafe conditions in mines to extract cobalt and coltan, two key minerals that all modern technology is reliant on. Major tech companies in the world, including Samsung, have been implicitly linked to the human rights abuses that the people of the DRC have been going through for years.
The IT multinational is dependent upon Congolese cobalt as a key element in lithiumion batteries used to produce their array of electronics. However, irresponsible cobalt sourcing practices undertaken by Tier 1 suppliers, Glencore and Huayou, have resulted in ASM operations being incorporated into Samsung’s global value chain, as Tier 2 suppliers. Analysis of the relationships underpinning Samsung’s cobalt value chain theoretical framework, highlights the presence of a relational governance structure, with captive elements among upstream Tier 1 and Tier 2 suppliers. Samsung is thereby reliant upon both Glencore and Huayou to transmit and enforce private codes of conduct down the value chain to expel human rights abuses.
— Daniel Krummel, Patrick Siegfried, BLOOD,SWEAT AND COBALT
With many fans becoming increasingly aware of the DRC’s condition, TXT’s close association with the brand has caused serious discomfort.
.@TXT_bighit As ambassadors of Samsung that will subsequently promote the consumption of more electronics that source materials at the expense of millions of Congolese lives as well as them being a major Zionist company, you are currently complicit in genocide. https://t.co/TJLhYKhtxP
— HYBE Boycott Updates (@hybeboycotts) July 11, 2024
Do NOT stream TXT's song created for Samsung. Besides boycotting HYBE, Samsung still has an investment inside of Israel AND is also a large contributor to the cause of the genocide in Congo & is an extremely unethical company #하이브는시오니스트를퇴출하라 #GalaxyxTXT https://t.co/Y2Ea7fS0qG pic.twitter.com/Cg3JKVQlwB
— M{om}ariah 🍉 (@fairyofstylish) July 17, 2024
Another reason why many MOAs are not happy about this collaboration is the fact that nearly 6,500 Samsung Electronics employees in South Korea have announced an indefinite strike, demanding better pay and benefits. From many global fans’ perspectives, not boycotting Samsung at this point in time would be the same as crossing a real-life picket line.
Finding out that Samsung employees are on strike brings with startling clarity why the TXT ambassadorship was released yesterday
— nalalala ❕❔ (@pinqbby) July 12, 2024
To MOAS (& ARMYs) Look at this!nThis is how cos use your faves to shift your opinion. Samsung is a Korean company. It's included in one of the biggest GDP contributors of SK. Samsung collaboration with TXT (or BTS) shouldn't stop you from boycotting! It's an INDEFINITE boycott https://t.co/kTQstCvSZN
— pb⁷ Yoongi misser🍉 (@snoozingyoongi) July 11, 2024
reminder that txt's song with samsung is coming out tomorrow (july 17th) and it's necessary to let everyone know that we should boycott this song as well as not supporting this collab
THE PEOPLE ALWAYS WIN! #하이브는시오니스트를퇴출하라 #GalaxyxTXT
— tris 🍉 HYBE BOYCOTT (@everynsoul) July 16, 2024
FYI. Because of this I will boycott the TXT / Samsung ads https://t.co/Gno5OcCHeV
— Joanna | ᜇᜒᜌᜓᜏᜈ | ジョアンナ ⁷ ⁺ ⁵ (@PinayYonsei) July 10, 2024
Samsung’s ongoing trade relations with Israel and its sponsorship of the Olympics, which the BDS (Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions) movement has named as a boycott target for not holding Israel accountable for its crimes against humanity in Palestine, is also another reason behind MOAs’ discontent with this collaboration.
today was "Korea-Israel Innovation Day" in the south 🤢 Samsung, Hyundai and LG among others looking to expand collaboration with Zionist tech firms pic.twitter.com/EsQg6s0ioe
— Natalie Everhart 🇰🇵 (@NatalieRevolts) July 16, 2024
hey just so everyone knows the olympics is being boycotted for allowing israel to participate! and samsung is actively involved with the genocide in congo!
— cam! 誓い (@momentsofsoobs) July 10, 2024
Let's NOT trend this and instead talk about Congo, in the genocide of which Samsung is involved in! AND ntm Samsung has SRIL Samsung Research & Developement Institute of Israel established in 1997 in an ongoing apartheid state. How about we talk about Palestine & Congo instead?🫶🏻 https://t.co/xrbA9U0tFO
— pb⁷ Yoongi misser🍉 (@snoozingyoongi) July 10, 2024
Actually, Samsung still has an investment inside of Israel & is contributing to the genocide in Congo, so regardless since it is TXT doing a sponsorship with them… the song should definitely be boycotted along with their campaign with Samsung https://t.co/XsOdkqiPzl
— M{om}ariah 🍉 (@fairyofstylish) July 10, 2024
Many were also displeased with how little Beomgyu was present on the track. That is, however, a minor concern in relation to the rest.
don't stop voicing out about the mistreatment. HEA and this collab should be enough to open up everyones eyes that bighit doesn't respect beomgyu as an artist and a member!
PLEASE RESPECT BEOMGYU@TXT_bighit @BIGHIT_MUSIC#BeomgyuDeservesLines pic.twitter.com/1yfo1VQxyh
— cbgstwt (@cbgstwt) July 17, 2024
make sure to boycott ‘open always wins’ as samsung is complicit in the congo gen0cide and because beomgyu has barely got any lines once again which should be your other reason to boycott
— mina (@hk2ai) July 17, 2024
Overall, TXT’s “Open Always Wins” for Samsung seems to have failed to win over all of their fandom, a significant portion of which wants their music to be as distant from social-distress-causing conglomerates as possible.